Adviisa home

Advisers · 28 Sept 2026

What happens to good advice when the people move on?

A business can be well advised and still struggle to explain its own history once a finance director leaves or an adviser retires. Russell sets out what companies and their advisers should agree to keep after important work.

Russell Gould, Founding CEO

A business can have good lawyers, accountants and tax advisers, and still struggle to explain its own history.

Each firm may understand its part. The founder may remember the commercial objective. The finance director may know which recommendations were acted on. The difficulty comes when somebody needs to connect those accounts — especially after one of those people has left.

In my earlier article,What will your company’s AI actually know?, I explored what happens when AI encounters incomplete or conflicting company history. That raises a more immediate question for the people advising businesses today: how much of the understanding created through their work remains usable over time?

For me, this is a business leadership question. We ask advisers to help us make important decisions. We also need to take responsibility for what the business retains from that work.

The gap can sit between well-run relationships

Consider a hypothetical owner-managed business that reorganises its group before seeking investment.

Its lawyers document the structure. Its tax advisers explain the conditions behind their advice. Its accountants reflect the changes in the accounts. The board makes the commercial decision.

Two years later, a new finance director is preparing for another funding discussion. The documents are available, but some questions remain. Why was one option chosen over another? Was the recommendation adopted in full? Did a later change affect an assumption on which the advice depended?

The founder remembers the intention. The former finance director handled the detail. An adviser who knew the background has since retired.

The new team may be able to reconstruct the answer. But that takes work, and it may reveal uncertainties that nobody knew were there.

No single adviser necessarily had a remit to maintain the whole account. Each engagement could have been handled competently while the connections between them became harder to establish.

That is the gap I think deserves more attention.

Better-prepared clients create room for better advice

For an adviser, this is a practical commercial issue.

Time spent locating a signed agreement or reconciling competing versions of a decision is time that cannot yet be spent assessing the client's next move. Under a fixed fee, avoidable reconstruction can erode margin. Where additional time is charged, it can be difficult for the client to understand why old ground needs to be covered again.

A client who can explain the starting position, provide supporting material and identify what has changed gives an adviser more to work with. Gaps can be investigated earlier. Questions can be more specific. The scope of further work can be clearer.

That does not make every engagement cheaper or faster. It does create the possibility of spending more professional time on the judgement the client needs now.

It matters within a continuing relationship too. A firm may return to its own work years later with a different team. The benefits of continuity do not begin only when a client changes advisers.

Asking again is sometimes the right thing to do

A new adviser still needs to reach their own conclusions. Facts change, the purpose of the work changes, and earlier advice may have relied on conditions that no longer hold.

The useful distinction is between checking something again and having to find the starting point again.

The profession already recognises the importance of handovers. ICAEW's guidance for outgoing accountants addresses permission, confidentiality, professional enquiries and the transfer of records.[1] Its guidance on changes within a firm also recognises the value of a handover period when the engagement partner changes, while acknowledging that one is not always possible.[2]

Those are examples within ICAEW's framework, rather than rules for every profession. They also show that continuity is an established concern.

The broader question is what happens between engagements, between firms and between the people inside the business who understand how the pieces connect.

Responsibility needs to be agreed

I would like business leaders to ask a simple question when a significant piece of work is completed: what will somebody need to understand about this decision in three years?

The answer might already be in the advice. Where it is not, the company and its advisers can agree what explanation is appropriate to preserve, who will retain it and who needs to be told if the facts change.

For a material decision, I would want to distinguish the advice received, the decision management made and the action actually taken. Those are not always the same thing.

The tax profession makes a related point explicitly. PCRT, effective from January 2026, says members should keep timely notes explaining the judgements exercised in applying its tax-planning standards.[3] That does not mean every working paper must become a client deliverable. It does reinforce the importance of retaining the reasoning behind professional judgements.

The company's part matters just as much. An adviser cannot account for a later decision they were never told about. Management needs to agree who keeps the relevant records current, and additional work should have an agreed scope and cost.

This is not a request to record every conversation. It is a question of preserving enough understanding around the decisions that could matter later.

AI makes this more relevant

AI can help organise records, connect related material and identify inconsistencies. Used well, it could make the starting position much easier to investigate.

It does not remove the need to establish what can be shared or relied upon. SRA confidentiality guidance for solicitors in England and Wales constrains disclosure.[4] Privilege and document ownership raise separate questions. Information can be exchanged appropriately, but access to a company's systems does not automatically confer access to its advisers' files.

Professional responsibility remains too. The PCRT bodies' January 2026 AI guidance says professionals remain responsible for their work and should be able to explain how conclusions were reached, including when AI was used.[5]

Where the available records support more than one account of a past decision, a fluent explanation alone does not resolve the uncertainty. Someone still needs to investigate what can be established and make clear what cannot.

That is why I see an important role for advisers in this discussion. Their judgement helps a business understand the significance and limitations of what it holds.

As businesses and advisers adopt more AI, that understanding becomes an important foundation for its use. Preserving it also has immediate value for the next conversation with a lender, investor, board or professional adviser.

What would change in your next engagement if the client arrived able to explain its important decisions — and show the evidence behind them?

Sources

1.ICAEW — Change of professional appointment: outgoing accountant, updated 29 October 2025 (restricted-access resource).

2.ICAEW — Changes in the composition of a firm, updated 10 January 2025 (restricted-access resource).

3.Professional Conduct in Relation to Taxation, effective 1 January 2026, paragraph 3.2.

4.SRA — Confidentiality of client information.

5.PCRT — Ethical use of artificial intelligence tools, 19 January 2026, introduction and paragraph 1.4.

The company example is hypothetical. The commercial argument and practical proposals are my views.

Russell Gould, Founding CEO · 28 Sept 2026

This article was first published on LinkedIn.